Skip to Content

Built To Meet Your Needs

Selling Options

How to Sell Your Diamonds for Cash
Our team of diamond experts at Cash In Your Diamonds will be pleased to give you a free appraisal and cash offer for any type of diamond. Each of our cash for diamond transactions is discreet and confidential.

To begin, we ask that you email or fax us all paperwork you received when your diamond was purchased. This should include the diamond’s appraisal and a copy of the diamond certification (GIA, EGL, AGS, IGI, HRD). Once we have received your paperwork, one of our specialists will conduct a detailed evaluation based on your diamond’s value in the current market to ensure that you receive the best offer for your diamond. Each seller is personally contacted by one of our experts with a firm cash offer within 24 hours of receiving the paperwork.

If you do not have the paperwork or diamond certification, we can still get you cash for your diamond. However, to ensure that we give you the best diamond purchasing experience and maximum value for your piece, we must personally view the diamond to complete an appraisal.

How to Begin Your Diamond Evaluation
After a brief conversation with one of our specialists about your unique piece, we will recommend that you send us your diamond in one of two ways:

  1. Insured U.S. Registered Mail
    The least expensive way to ship your diamond is via insured U.S. registered mail. Be sure to follow all wrapping instructions and maintain a copy of all paperwork. Click here for more information.
  2. Insured UPS Overnight
    When sending your diamond UPS, you must buy insurance for your diamond, which is listed under Item #6: Optional Services. Be sure to check this item box and write in a value. When sending, we recommend that you do not wrap/place the diamond in the package at the UPS store, but wrap/pack the diamond safely and discreetly at home.

Please send your diamond to us at the following address:

Stafford’s
2555 St. Rt. 725
Dayton, Ohio 45459

What Happens When Your Diamond Arrives
When your diamond arrives, it is signed for and placed in a secured room to be opened by two of our diamond experts. Once the package is opened, the diamond is examined and graded. After the grading is complete, you will be called to confirm or receive an official offer. Each step of our diamond handling process is recorded to give you additional security and peace of mind.

Choosing Payment for Your Diamond
After our offer to purchase your diamond is accepted, you may choose to receive your payment by either a bank wire transfer or a company check, which will be overnighted to you. If you are already present in our offices for the appraisal because you are a local resident or chose to accept our offer to fly to Dayton, you may be able to receive your check on the spot in as little as 15 minutes.

Get Cash for Your Diamond!
We understand that finding the right company to trust with an important sale such as this is of the utmost importance. That’s why we guarantee your satisfaction with each step in this transaction. If you have any questions, or would like to discuss your particular situation, please contact us.